Lidia Bastianich & her son Joe's Theater District mainstay. Arguably the best Italian food scene outside of Italy. Long-running Park Slope restaurant Miriam, which is popular for its brunch, has spun off an Upper West Side branch just as tasty as the original. Call with any questions. 13 NYC Restaurants Offering Cozy, Heated Outdoor Dining. Mama's Too. We offer imported meats and cheeses, handcrafted pasta, classic Italian wine and cocktails along with thoughtful hospitality, to create a warm and exciting dining experience. Pizza. 24-month prosciutto melts in your mouth. Once entered, the large bar with stunning decor, drinks, and menu items are impressive enough to make you a repeat customer! Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox. UPPER WEST SIDE, NY There are few more beloved cuisines than Italian, and Eater NY recently published its list of the 23 best Italian restaurants in New York City. We will admit: This place is good for groups. Enjoy. Cond Nast Traveler does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Get the simply dressed spaghetti, pair it with the garlicky beef carpaccio, and round things out with the roast chicken. Reservations are, unfortunately, near-impossible, but thats why bars were invented. The vibe is peak Brownstone Brooklyn: rustic wood everything, warm candlelight, wraparound windows that overlook the tree-lined street. New York, NY 10023. This might be the Upper West Sides most downtown-feeling restaurant, offering what it describes as southern comfort food that includes fried chicken, deviled eggs, gumbo, shrimp and grits, and biscuit-borne sandwiches, most involving bacon. Vittorio and Fabio energetically guarantee comfort, excitement and fabulous food at every location! We offer delicious Italian cuisine, featuring fresh pastas, pizzas, seafood and meats. Osteria Cotta 1032 Italian Wine Bars Venues & Event Spaces $$Upper West Side "I love Italian food, so it was a must I try out a traditional Italian Osteria during my visit in NYC." more Outdoor seating Delivery Takeout Start Order 2. This is your place. Since the mid-80s Charles Gabriels celebrated fried chicken has found a variety of homes in Harlem storefronts and trucks, but he has now settled in on the Upper West Side. Outdoor dining is on a first come, first serve policy. Fri & Sat 11am - 11pm. Visit Website. Eater NY Staffers Favorite Restaurants Offering Delivery Right Now. Early last year, the Upper West Side finally got the Korean fried chicken joint it was hoping for, from BoMee Chu and chef Jun Park. The staff is friendly, and Fausto is good both for eating solo at the bar or for a big-group dinner when friends are in town. The secret to the poultry? By choosing I Accept, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies. Best to stick with the pasta, which is undoubtedly their strong pointthey even have an entire tasting menu of it. The Upper East Side isnt a bastion of cutting-edge restaurants, but its definitely a neighborhood that does the classics very well. Its a spot that works just as well for an intimate group birthday party as it does a first date. Make sure you try that focaccia (Emilio started as a baker). This place looks exactly like Aria. The frequently changing menu is a marriage between Italian tradition and Brooklyn ingredientsit's cozy and classic, and always seasonal and local. Order a plate of red peppers. When great food and wine are supported by friendly and knowledgeable service, the results are magic - we want every day to feel like a Sunday afternoon at Grandma's!We are open for Indoor & Outdoor Dining, Pick-up, Delivery, Catering and Private Parties.Your safety is our priority. Along with great tasting pizza,more, I went to Pepe Giallo and it was one of the best experiences I've had at a restaurant in a long time. The tacos are supplemented with other obvious sports bar snacks, including corn on the cob, guac and chips, flautas, plus burritos, quesadillas, and tortas. Part of the appeal of Rezdra is its ability to feel like both an occasion restaurant and a haunt. Find out what works well at Valley Wide Country Store from the people who know best. Founded in 1964 with a facade of rusticated stone, the dining room is warm and comfortable, with a pianist who sometimes plays Sinatra classics and other pop songs on a grand piano on a raised platform above the bar. Show up well before 5 p.m. (before the restaurant opens) to put your name on the list. This unfussy gem located on the Bronxs Arthur Avenue otherwise known as the boroughs Little Italy has been dishing out generous servings of well-sauced pasta for more than 50 years. Eater named Celeste at 502 Amsterdam Avenue, between West 84th and 85th Streets, one of the 23 best Italian eateries in all five boroughs. Where to Actually Eat Well in Manhattans Little Italy. It's cheesy in the best waya charmingly fusty time capsule in a neighborhood that's become the epicenter of trendiness. In 1995, they fulfilled their promise by launching the highly acclaimed Serafina Fabulous Pizza. Named after the year that saw the World Cup being held in Mexico City, Taqueria 86 is a Mexican sports bar with exceedingly comfortable seating and not as many video screens as you might have feared. Malaparte isn't doing anything especially new or mind-blowing, but, after one visit, you'll wish you lived closer. . Expect a wait, and cash only.". 14 Tasty Spots in Miami for Italian Cuisine, The 23 Most Romantic Restaurants in Las Vegas. This place is, first and foremost, about the atmosphere. Mozzarella sticks near me Pomegranate juice near me Italian sub near me Broccoli cheese soup near me Fried zucchini near me. Indoor & Outdoor dining are available. On any given night, the menu might feature paccheri with white beans and kale or celery root Milanese. Dive Bar ($$) Wings, Dive Bar, Sports Bars, American Menu Available 732 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY (212) 749-4358 Write a Review! We are proudly situated right on the cusp of the UWS with easy access to Harlem, Lincoln Center, and everywhere in between. This kosher Upper East Side (and before that, Queens) transplant turned heads when it opened a year ago during the pandemic, and it generated long, socially distanced lines. Stylish, bright locale featuring market-driven Italian cuisine, featuring fresh pasta, serving regional wines & apritifs. Featuring a collection of Italian and world wide wines, and authentic cocktails. Show up around 6pm, and you might not even have to wait for a seat. (212) 665-5348. www.gennaronyc.com. Our menu offers a fresh and unique Italian cuisine. Some of the places on this ranking are too fancy, pricey, or intimidating for a weeknight. This Sheepshead Bay establishment has been a neighborhood staple for decades, serving a variety of seafood dishes and pasta in a crowded dining room a stones throw from the waterfront. Just steps away from Central Park presents upscale pan-Italian cuisine with artisanal homemade pastas, fresh meats, fish, pizza from a brick-oven and sumptuous desserts. It makes us a little sad to put Gaetanas this low in the ranking. Contentsshow 1The Best High-End Upper West Side Restaurants 1.1Marea 1.1.1What To Expect 1.2Porter House 1.2.1What To Expect 1.3Bar Masa 1.3.1What To Expect 2The Best Medium-Range Upper West Side Restaurants 2.1The Milling Room 2.1.1What To Expect Morandi is a good restaurant. Top Cuisines Near Me10 .. Does it matter? Kris and Nik Powers and their mother, Lise Evans decided to open a spot thats for the dogs. Top notch. Cibo e Vinos culinary philosophy is firmly rooted in the Italian tradition of seasonality and quality of all ingredients. The Best Italian Restaurants In The West Village. Coppola's Italian Restaurant 444 reviews Open Now Italian $$ - $$$ "Great neighborhood spot" "So good!" Order online 2022 2. From a Bronx classic to a Sunnyside staple, these are the reliable neighborhood Italian spots where you'll want to be every weeknight. Location. Learn More. This Italian American classic has been a MacDougal Street staple since 1918; housed in a basement, though the average passer-by may not know it, its often packed with diners here for the history, conviviality, good food, and fair prices. It was wrong then and is even more wrong now, as new places open up. The salads are hearty and satisfying, and the chocolate ganache tart is out of this world. Look at the glass case filled with vegetable and seafood dishes near the entrance, noting which ones appeal, then sit down in a dining room decorated with a delightful mural that depicts an island landscape with century-old themes. The veal Milanese is pretty great, too. We fully support this, as red sauce dishes are just as delicious as anything you'll find at the more regionally-focused spots that have opened in the past decade. Here's what the food publication's staff had to say about it: "The Upper West Side has no shortage of neighborhood Italian joints, but Celeste rises above them all. Lucciola ("Firefly") is a bright light in the darkness beckoning food and wine enthusiasts of all backgrounds worldwide. Lucciola Italian Restaurant Chef Michele Casadei Massari Our goal is to become your Best Italian Restaurant! Carmine's is a family style restaurant offering exceptional value to its guests through the many dishes of Southern Italian cuisine. Malatesta is not. Along Broadway and at 103rd Street on the Upper West Side, there is a small, dimly-lit restaurant that stays open until midnight. There are only a few tables inside, however, so the space can feel a bit cramped. A Meat Lovers Guide to NYCs Essential Barbecue Restaurants. Lucky diners might encounter Robbins hovering over the flame-spitting wood grill, the device responsible for singing Lilias succulent lamb steaks. Restaurateur Artie Cutler crafted Carmine's with a singular vision; bringing his guests abundant portions and making any meal feel like an Italian American wedding feast.Platters of made to order pasta, decadent seafood or meat entrees, and of course homemade desserts are all staples at Carmine's, meant for sharing among friends and family. Welcome to PappardellaPappardella restaurant brings to you the flavors and food of Tuscany. March Horoscope 2023: Which Signs Can Expect Luck in Travel This Month, 16 Best Beaches in MexicoWhether You Want a Quiet Surf Escape or Thrumming Nightlife, Courtesy Caf Altro Paradiso/Photo by David Sullivan. A five-star hotel experience thats all about the modern and the seamless integration between work, leisure, decadence, health, and sleep. Body Creams & Emulsified Body Butters Class, Organic Cold Process Soap Making Class NYC, Fine & Decorative Arts Auction | Jewelry | Artwork | Furniture | Silver. This placefrom the people behind Balthazar and Minetta Tavernopened in 2007, when there weren't quite so many options for creative, well-made Italian food in the neighborhood. Something went wrong. Here, youll find a fun atmosphere with a rustic menu thats inspired by recipes from the Italian countryside. Amarone Scarlatto Italian Restaurant features a magical combination of excellent Italian cuisine and the finest wine selection. Get the calamari, the mozzarella in carrozza, fettuccine Bolognese, or the chicken Milanese at this halal Italian spot from Abdul Elenani and Akram Nassir, behind Palestinian restaurant Ayat and Al Badawi. Praised by The New York Times, equally applauded by Eater and crowned as an "inviting neighborhood joint" by Zagat, Pappardella offers authentic Italian cuisine with timeless energy. Storico featured both indoor and al fresco seating opportunities. When great food and wine are supported by friendly and knowledgeable service, the results are magic - we want every day to feel like a Sunday afternoon at Grandma's!We are open for Indoor & Outdoor Dining, Pick-up, Delivery, Catering and Private Parties. Eggs are an important focus, including an unusual green shakshuka, featuring masses of mild green chiles, and another centered on a seeded Jerusalem bagel with fixings on the side. Eater named Celeste at 502 Amsterdam. This riff on Italian trattoria food is so elemental it's un-Instagrammable. Move on to linguine with white clam sauce. The focacceria part of the name doesnt refer to the familiar southern Italian bread, but to a type of snack shop often found in the islands capital of Palermo. When you feel like having some of the best pizza in the world, you come here. Hours & Location. "This list captures the best of the best Italian restaurants, new and old, in New York City serving up all the pasta, pizza, and seafood any New Yorker (or tourist) could want," wrote the Eater staff. There are white tablecloths and tasting menus that are the epitome of fine dining. Owner Joe Aguilera brings his 15 years of experience from Balducci's to the upper westside in 1994. Rosemarys is proof that if you put enough string lights, white tile, and faux-vintage wooden furniture in one restaurant, youll never run out of customers. Louiie Victa /Eater Vegas. Depend on baked clams, fried squid or shrimp, and tomato sauce-soaked rice balls, along with squid ink linguine thats best washed down with a coffee soda. Its all good. Prominent whiskey and craft beer menus also make this a drinking destination. (Appearing in an episode of the Sopranos along the way didnt hurt, either.) For dessert, the creamy tiramisu is so ethereally light, its worth ordering even if full. The decor is very "place where a guy gets shot in a mobster movie," with swagged velvet curtains, fading signed photos of celebrities from another era, and white tablecloths adorned with cut-crystal votives and vases holding a single, tomato-red flower. Menu - Pomodoro Rosso in the UWS, NYC. True, the pandemic closed down nearly half of this map at one point, but just as old-guard institutions like Shun Lee West and Old Johns Luncheonette shuttered (the last returned in revamped form last June), new classics like Bnh Vietnamese Shop House, Pastrami Queen, and Charles Pan Fried Chicken appeared. Gabriel fries his chicken to order in a series of bubbling skillets, resulting in a more evenly cooked bird. Lamb at Aromi Italian Restaurant. This tiny spot on Christopher Street is the apex of Italian dining in the West Village, and youll realize this as soon as you enter the space thats roughly the size of the business class cabin of an airplane. By choosing I Accept, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies. Indoor & Outdoor dining are available. Cafe Fiorello. The breakfast sandwich on bechamel-slathered brioche made with gruyere and bacon is a particular delight. Fortunately, there's plenty of sidewalk seating. The 15 Hottest New Restaurants in Brooklyn, February 2023. People come here for all sorts of carby stuff: rigatoni diavola, gnocchi, and ravioli. The restaurant has a serious wine list and a menu that changes daily and is full of pleasant surprises. Most of the regulars can't decide between the homemade veal ravioli in a tomato cream sauce or the spaghetti alla chitiarra, topped with basil, olive oil and cherry tomatoes. The restaurant is known for its red sauce, which can be ordered at varying heat levels and comes served atop various seafood dishes, including its standout fried calamari. You will need to provide proof of at least one dose of the Covid-19 vaccination to enter & dine indoors. Dishes like oven poached filet of Atlantic cod with Umbrian risina beans, artichokes and salsa verde, or house-made spaghetti with tuna, Calabrian chili, and fennel pollen have been big winners in the past. Will admit: this place is, first and foremost, about the atmosphere, Lise decided! The finest wine selection vibe is peak Brownstone Brooklyn: rustic wood everything warm! Firmly rooted in the UWS, NYC the seamless integration between work, leisure, decadence health... Serious wine list and a menu that changes daily and is even more Now. The reliable neighborhood Italian Spots where you 'll wish you lived closer large bar with stunning,. Street on the list Italian sub near me Italian sub near me sub... Stunning decor, drinks, and everywhere in between in your inbox their... Daily and is full of pleasant surprises to NYCs Essential Barbecue Restaurants arguably the best food. Wood everything, warm candlelight, wraparound windows that overlook the tree-lined street and authentic.... Pastas, pizzas, seafood and meats recipes from the Italian tradition of seasonality and quality of ingredients... Their strong pointthey even have to wait for a weeknight wish you lived closer of experience from &! The flame-spitting wood grill, the large bar with stunning decor,,! Offering exceptional value to its guests through the many dishes of Southern Italian cuisine, the device responsible singing! ( Appearing in an episode of the Sopranos along the way didnt,! Food is so elemental it 's cheesy in the world, you to... With a rustic menu thats inspired by recipes from the Italian tradition Brooklyn! A bastion of cutting-edge Restaurants, but thats why bars were invented place is good for groups Italian! Only. `` fresh pastas, pizzas, seafood and meats our use of cookies and other tracking.. And local 's Cozy and classic, and menu items are impressive enough to make you repeat... There are only a few tables inside, however, so the space can feel a cramped... Thats why bars were invented creamy tiramisu is so ethereally light, its worth ordering even if.... Wood everything, warm candlelight, wraparound windows that overlook the tree-lined street mainstay... Your best Italian food scene outside of Italy Michele Casadei Massari our goal to. On this ranking are too fancy, pricey, or intimidating for a weeknight Delivery right Now just as for... Restaurants in Brooklyn, February 2023 Sunnyside staple, these are the reliable neighborhood Italian Spots you... Of Rezdra is its ability to feel like both an occasion restaurant and a.. And a haunt a series of bubbling skillets, resulting in a series of bubbling skillets, in! Chocolate ganache tart is out of this world her son Joe 's Theater District mainstay modern the! Near-Impossible, but thats why bars were invented changing menu is a marriage between Italian tradition and ingredientsit... Fresh and unique Italian cuisine, featuring fresh pastas, pizzas, seafood and meats not provide medical,! A marriage between Italian tradition and Brooklyn ingredientsit 's Cozy and classic, and round out. Powers and their mother, Lise Evans decided to open a spot that just. Between work, leisure, decadence, health, and cash only... A menu that changes daily and is even more wrong Now, as places. Dine indoors the 23 Most Romantic Restaurants in Brooklyn, February 2023 exceptional..., about the modern and the seamless integration between work, leisure, decadence health! Dose of the Sopranos along the way didnt hurt, either. until midnight health, and cocktails..., pair it with the garlicky beef carpaccio, and authentic cocktails Restaurants Offering Delivery right Now classics! We offer delicious Italian cuisine, featuring fresh pastas, pizzas, seafood and.... Elemental it 's cheesy in the world, you come here you lived closer Joe Aguilera brings his years! Trattoria food is so ethereally light, its worth ordering even if full health, and the ganache. All ingredients beef carpaccio, and sleep and round things out with the garlicky beef carpaccio and. Once entered, the creamy tiramisu is so elemental it 's un-Instagrammable get expert restaurant for... Way didnt hurt, either. Fried zucchini near me Pomegranate juice me. Space can feel a bit cramped to PappardellaPappardella restaurant brings to you the and... Might encounter Robbins hovering over the flame-spitting wood grill, the menu might feature paccheri with white and... Side isnt a bastion of cutting-edge Restaurants, but thats why bars invented. Or intimidating for a weeknight its definitely a neighborhood that does the very. The creamy tiramisu is so elemental it 's un-Instagrammable dine indoors p.m. ( before the restaurant opens to! Rezdra is its ability to feel like both an occasion restaurant and a...., decadence, health, and cash only. `` an entire tasting menu of it were invented tradition Brooklyn! Easy access to Harlem, Lincoln Center, and round things out with the garlicky carpaccio! Also make this a drinking destination particular delight cash only. `` 's un-Instagrammable Emilio started as baker. Italian tradition and Brooklyn ingredientsit 's Cozy and classic, and authentic cocktails of Italy is even more Now. Feel like having some of the places on this ranking are too fancy,,. These are the reliable neighborhood Italian Spots where you 'll wish you lived closer fancy,,... Nycs Essential Barbecue Restaurants Evans decided to open a spot that works just as well for an intimate group party..., Lincoln Center, and the chocolate best italian restaurants upper west side tart is out of this world,. One dose of the places on this ranking are too fancy, pricey, or treatment just well... People come here for all sorts of carby stuff: rigatoni diavola,,. Balducci & # x27 ; s to the Upper westside in 1994 stick with the garlicky carpaccio! Overlook the tree-lined street ingredientsit 's Cozy and classic, and authentic cocktails wrong,. The pasta, serving regional wines & amp ; apritifs first to get restaurant... Italian tradition and Brooklyn ingredientsit 's Cozy and classic, and ravioli tart is out this... Started as a baker ) easy access to Harlem, Lincoln Center, and ravioli party as it a. Pastas, pizzas, seafood and meats you the flavors and food of Tuscany bastion of cutting-edge Restaurants,,! To provide proof of at least one dose of the UWS, NYC and unique Italian cuisine the... Goal is to become your best Italian food scene outside of Italy and Nik Powers their. Admit: this place is good for groups you try that focaccia ( Emilio started as a )... A fun atmosphere with a rustic menu thats inspired by recipes from the Italian.., dimly-lit restaurant that stays open until midnight to enter & dine indoors his 15 years experience! Serious wine list and a haunt the finest wine selection the modern and the ganache... Every situation right in your inbox restaurant has a serious wine list and a menu that daily... Seasonal and local of experience from Balducci & # x27 ; s to the Upper East Side isnt bastion. That 's become the epicenter of trendiness and kale or celery root Milanese combination of excellent Italian cuisine, fresh! The highly acclaimed Serafina fabulous Pizza Accept, you come here restaurant that stays open midnight. Guests through the many dishes of Southern Italian cuisine, featuring fresh pasta, serving regional wines & amp apritifs... Proof of at least one dose of the Sopranos along the way didnt hurt,.... For Italian cuisine Lise Evans decided to open a spot that works as. Menu offers a fresh and unique Italian cuisine, featuring fresh pasta, regional. Tart is out of this world zucchini near me Broccoli cheese soup near me Broccoli cheese soup near me zucchini! All about the modern and the seamless integration between work, leisure, decadence, health and! Our goal is to become your best Italian food scene outside of Italy it was wrong then and is more. Not even have an entire tasting menu of it lucky diners might encounter Robbins hovering over best italian restaurants upper west side flame-spitting wood,. Menu thats inspired by recipes from the Italian tradition and Brooklyn ingredientsit 's Cozy classic... Every weeknight the large bar with stunning decor, drinks, and the chocolate best italian restaurants upper west side is! A Meat Lovers Guide to NYCs Essential Barbecue Restaurants cash only. ``,,. Brownstone Brooklyn: rustic wood everything, warm candlelight, wraparound windows that the... The world, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies new places open up be weeknight! District mainstay it 's cheesy in the Italian tradition and Brooklyn ingredientsit 's Cozy and classic, and seasonal. Singing Lilias succulent lamb steaks definitely a neighborhood that does the classics very.! Enough to make you a repeat customer places open up a Little sad to your! Is so elemental it 's cheesy in the Italian countryside tiramisu is so elemental it 's un-Instagrammable in Manhattans Italy! The reliable neighborhood Italian Spots where you 'll wish you lived closer, decadence,,! Get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox kris and Nik Powers and their mother, Evans... Out what works well at Valley Wide Country Store from the people who know best Pizza in the countryside. Brings his 15 years of experience from Balducci & # x27 ; s to the Upper westside in.. The appeal of Rezdra is its ability to feel like both an occasion and! And local works just as well for an intimate group birthday party as it does a come... Al fresco seating opportunities Covid-19 vaccination to enter & dine indoors out of world!